Hidden in Print

Black history and life as seen through Savannah’s newspapers

Because sometimes the most revealing history isn’t hidden at all. It was printed in the newspaper.

Frank Leslie’s Illustrated Newspaper, New York, March 13, 1880 · not Savannah.
Frank Leslie’s Illustrated Newspaper, New York, March 13, 1880 · not Savannah.

Colored Lawyer Argues a Creative Defense for His Client

“It is a well-known axiom that a blow on the head of a Caucasian will cause death where in the case of a colored man there will be no serious results.”

In 1903 Savannah attorney J. H. Kinckle told the Police Court his client’s knife attack wasn’t a felony, because “a blow in a negro’s head was not likely to produce death.”

Narration0:00

William Brown stood in Savannah’s Police Court charged with stabbing B. W. Munds in the head. The evidence was strong. The only question before Recorder Myrick was how serious the crime would be: a misdemeanor for the City Court, or assault with intent to murder, a felony for the Superior Court.

Brown’s lawyer was J. H. Kinckle, whom the Savannah Morning News called “a colored attorney.” He wanted the lesser charge. On December 3, 1903, the paper printed his argument:

“It is a well-known axiom that a blow on the head of a Caucasian will cause death where in the case of a colored man there will be no serious results.”

The knife, the paper reported, had been “driven into Mund’s head,” and Munds “had a close call.” Kinckle asked the Recorder to see it his way:

“The colored attorney urged the Recorder to act on the theory that the crime could not have been one of assault with intent to murder, because a blow in a negro’s head was not likely to produce death.”

The Recorder was not persuaded:

“But the Recorder could not see the logic of Kinckle’s argument and Brown was remanded for trial in the Superior Court for committing a felonious assault.”

The headline over the story read: “Colored Lawyer’s Fight to Save His Client.”

As printed
The story as printed in the Savannah Morning News, December 3, 1903.
The story as printed in the Savannah Morning News, December 3, 1903.
Read the article

COLORED LAWYER’S FIGHT TO SAVE HIS CLIENT.

Contended That Blow on Head Was Not So Serious.

“It is a well-known axiom that a blow on the head of a Caucasian will cause death where in the case of a colored man there will be no serious results.”

In an effort to have his client turned over to the City Court for stabbing not in his own defense, rather than to the Superior Court for assault with intent to murder, J. H. Kinckle, a colored attorney, advanced this argument to Recorder Myrick in Police Court yesterday.

William Brown was arraigned for stabbing B. W. Munds in the head with a knife some time ago. The evidence against Brown was strong enough to warrant the Recorder in holding him, and the question was one of whether Brown should be tried for a misdemeanor or a felony. It was shown that the knife had been driven into Mund’s head and that he had a close call.

The colored attorney urged the Recorder to act on the theory that the crime could not have been one of assault with intent to murder, because a blow in a negro’s head was not likely to produce death. But the Recorder could not see the logic of Kinckle’s argument and Brown was remanded for trial in the Superior Court for committing a felonious assault.

Terms on this page

Recorder:
the judge of Savannah’s Police Court, which heard minor cases and decided which serious ones went on to a higher court.
Remanded:
sent back to jail to await trial.
Felonious assault:
an attack serious enough to be tried as a felony.

Source

Savannah Morning News, December 3, 1903, p. 12 (Georgia Historic Newspapers; reel 00414182422, seq. 860): “Colored Lawyer’s Fight to Save His Client. Contended That Blow on Head Was Not So Serious.”

See the full newspaper page ↗

More stories